zimmytws / Shutterstock.com
Cathy Engelbert is walking away from the WNBA commissioner’s chair, and she wants everyone to know it was her call.
The league confirmed the move Thursday. Engelbert’s resignation officially takes effect on December 31, wrapping up a tenure that began back in 2019 when she became the first person ever to hold the job. She broke the news herself, posting a statement through the WNBA’s official Instagram account that framed the exit as retirement on her own terms.
Not everyone in sports media is buying that version of events.
A Retirement — Or Something Else?
Bill Simmons, the former ESPN writer who went on to found The Ringer, predicted this exact outcome months ago. Back in the summer, he said the WNBA would have a new commissioner before long. Turns out he wasn’t far off.
Clay Travis, who’s built a chunk of his Outkick platform around covering the league’s controversies, didn’t hold back either. “Cathy Engelbert is ‘retiring,’ aka being fired. So the WNBA will have a new commissioner. Hopefully the new commissioner can tell us what a woman is,” he tweeted.
“Decided.” https://t.co/7XfCDvGn5h
— Brett Siegel (@BrettSiegelNBA) September 4, 2026
In her official statement, Engelbert leaned into the legacy angle rather than the drama:
“After more than seven years at the WNBA and more than 40 total years in business, I have made the decision to retire as WNBA Commissioner. In 2019, I had the privilege of being appointed the league’s first commissioner and to lead a league with enormous potential yet untapped awareness and significant undervaluation. Over the years, it has been amazing to watch WNBA players thrive and lead the massive cultural surge around women’s sports.”
She continued: “I retire knowing we have built something bigger, stronger and more enduring than we could have imagined. I am grateful to the WNBA and NBA team owners and staff, players, investors, fans and the powerhouse league office staff, who believed in what this league could become. I retire with immense gratitude and tremendous optimism for the future of the WNBA, with the best yet to come.”
A Season Unlike Any Other
Whatever the real reason for her departure, it’s hard to separate it from the season she’s leaving behind. The 2026 WNBA campaign has been, by most accounts, the most chaotic stretch in the league’s 30-year history.
Consider the list: Alyssa Thomas throwing a punch toward Caitlin Clark’s throat during a game; members of Congress sending letters demanding accountability from the league; a USA Today column that invoked Emmett Till; the ongoing controversy around Sophie Cunningham and transgender athletes in the league; DiJonai Carrington’s “WHITE PRIVILEGE” post that set off its own firestorm; and WNBA security reportedly telling fans at arenas to cover up shirts referencing XX and XY chromosomes.
Stephen A. Smith even took time to warn the league directly, saying “a lot of people don’t like you.” Simmons, for his part, went further than prediction — he publicly called for Engelbert’s firing.
She’s out after this season! Cathy Englebert will be a former WNBA Commissioner.
— Linda Cohn (@lindacohn) September 4, 2026
Adding to the noise: former NBA players like Enes Kanter and Royce White — who, worth noting, never actually appeared in an NBA game — have reportedly been angling for spots in the 2027 WNBA Draft. The discourse around the league has only intensified as a result.
Growth Alongside the Chaos
One fan summed up the sentiment circulating online: “The WNBA needs its David Stern. Someone willing to be unpopular for the sake of the league. Under Engelbert, the league had chance after chance to take off, and she blew it at every turn.”
That take ignores some real progress, though. Viewership records fell during Engelbert’s run. The league locked in a new broadcast deal. And Caitlin Clark’s arrival pushed the WNBA into a level of mainstream attention it hadn’t seen before — comparisons to a “Rookie of the Year effect” don’t really do it justice.
Still, plenty would argue the league spent more time defending itself in the culture wars than showcasing the talent actually on the court. Clark, Angel Reese, Paige Bueckers, Olivia Miles — there’s no shortage of players capable of carrying the WNBA into its next chapter.
Whoever takes over for Engelbert inherits both sides of that legacy: real growth, and a season that’s tested the league’s public image like never before.
