‘42’ Only Has Warning Track Power [MOVIE REVIEW]

Review by Phil Villarreal. Phil is an authorblogger and Twitterer.

SCORE: 2 stars (out of 4)

The movie 42 shows how back in 1947, Jackie Robinson changed a nation by facing overwhelming prejudice to shatter boundaries on the baseball diamond. With grace and skill, he proved that players with women’s names could do just as well as those with traditional dudes’ monikers.

Without Robinson’s trailblazing efforts, perhaps greats such as Minnie Minoso, Sandy Koufax, Gabby Hartnett and Nolan Ryan, (whose first name, I swear to you, is actually Lynn), might never have had the courage to pursue their dream.

As the movie tells it, Robinson engaged opposing pitchers in trite debates about whether or not he belonged on the field, before proving his worth with his extraordinary ability to get either walked or beaned in the head, then stealing every base to help the Brooklyn Dodgers win every game they played that season. Sometimes, when Robinson was tired and just wanted to get over with it and get back to the dugout to exchange stink-eyes with the team’s racists, he hit home runs while background orchestras played and he looked lovingly at his wife in the stands.

Robinson did more for dudes with female names’ rights than any politician or activist. It’s no wonder that every Major League team retired his jersey number, which was… Huh. Can’t seem to recall.

The movie is to be commended for the tirelessly accurate way it pays tribute to Robinson’s on and off-field trials. There’s also some subtle symbolism going on. Remember John C. McGinley, the sexist doctor from Scrubs who would always belittle Zach Braff’s character by calling him female names? The film turns that concept on its head by making McGinley play breathless Dodgers announcer Red Barber, who chronicles Robinson’s never-to-be-matched 1.000 batting average, 14 million bases on balls, 42 million stolen bases and 12 home runs. Each and every one of which the movie shows.

While Robinson’s story is worthy of respect and admiration, writer director Brian Helgeland shows conclusively that even a great man’s life can be incredibly repetitive and boring. The movie can find no other conflict or resolution than Robinson getting treated like crap, then proceeding to play such incredibly great baseball that it’s accompanied by extremely loud trumpet swells.

Like many a baseball game, the film is two-plus hours of monotony peppered with a few memorable thrills. Chadwick Boseman, as Jackie Robinson, does an excellent job of playing a man with a female name. One might argue, in fact, that Boseman does a better job of playing Robinson than Robinson himself did playing himself in The Jackie Robinson Story back in 1950.

Also, Harrison Ford does a solid job as Dodgers executive Branch Rickey, who, as baseball historians love to note, showed incredible bravery in bringing Robinson into the Majors. Poor Rickey had to sit there and watch as Robinson got hit in the head, spiked on the base paths and shunned in the locker room. Having to watch that must have made Rickey incredibly sad, even as he counted mounds of cash that Robinson made him, and Ford does a good job of conveying the plight of an incredibly rich, old man who watches stuff happen while wearing a poker face.

All in all, 42 isn’t quite up to the standards of the other movies in the series, 1 through 41. One can only hope that the inevitable sequel, 43, will be up to the task to return the franchise to its former glory.

Starring: Chadwick Boseman, Harrison Ford, John C. McGinley, Christopher Meloni, Lucas Black, Hamish Linklater and Nicole Behari. Written and directed by Brian Helgeland. 126 minutes. Rated PG-13.



  1. Your mother says:

    Cute review, I hope being cute works out for you.

  2. Deepak says:

    Aah, finally someone calls your standard Hollywood sports movie for just what it is – a boring an predictable slog through the exact same beats, no matter what sport it is! Kudos!

    1. Steve says:

      You and Phil Villarunreal are two pee's!! in a pod. Buff said!

    2. Deepak says:

      Thanks, you made my day, "Steve with the over aggressive spell checker on his tab/phone"

  3. AnthonyR. says:

    I don't know if the movie is good or not, but I know that your review fails miserably at being funny. Even Friedberg and Seltzer could make your review funnier… Alright, that's an exaggeratrion.

    1. Rach says:

      My favorite was the "inevitable sequel, 43." A number joke! How clever!

    2. Guest says:

      Yeah, trying much too hard to be funny here, and your jokes really fall flat. You can be clever without making blatant jokes that just aren't funny. Leave the jokes to the comedians, and just write a movie review.

  4. mozoRael says:

    Yeah, if you thought the movie was repetitive, you think you would have realized that so were your weak attempts at jokes. Your review also reveals how little you knew about Branch Ricky, Jackie Robinson and life in general. (Like Ricky just counted money and didn't recieve any death threats?) Good luck with whatever new career path you choose as this movie review business might not be a good fit.

  5. Ozella says:

    With one other with all in the help of those people people fulfilling intercourse matches for husbands and wives, possibilities have you been'll surely possess the prospect to revive the fires of lust and get pleasure from inside your unique daily lifestyle. You are able to also enlarge your perspectives when it calls for imaginativeness and creativeness. Extremely a number of corporations within just planet offer with this segment.

  6. Jacquetta says:

    Great post! I love reading this stuff. Keep up the good work!

  • You Might Like